Gary Neville did not hold back on his criticism of Manchester United centre-back Mathijs De Ligt following the Dutchman’s shaky performance in the 3-0 defeat to Liverpool. The former United defender pinpointed De Ligt’s poor form and limited game time as major concerns, calling for the club to move him on.
Neville’s frustrations with De Ligt have been mounting for months. Speaking on the United Stand podcast earlier this week with Mark Goldbridge, Neville listed De Ligt among the players he would offload, citing his lack of availability as a key issue. “He has got one big problem: he doesn’t play football,” Neville said. “If a player is injury-prone and doesn’t play football, just because he hasn’t played doesn’t mean he should go above a player who has played every single week and is throwing his hand up. You want someone who’s actually reliable and available to play. So, De Ligt has to go. I mean, seriously.”
In this story
Matthijs de Ligt
View profile
De Ligt’s appearances this year have been sparse. Under interim manager Michael Carrick, he made only two appearances, including a brief cameo against Roma and a rare start in a heavy defeat. Other squad members such as Cristiano Ronaldo, Jadon Sancho, and Donny van de Beek have received more minutes despite their own struggles.
Neville’s criticism intensified after De Ligt’s Premier League start against Liverpool, his first in over a year. The early stages of the match exposed the defender’s rustiness. He misjudged a long ball that led to a last-man foul by Lille’s Leny Yoro on Alexander Isak, resulting in a red card and an early setback for United.
“You watched him in Como four weeks ago, and he was very much off it, and that is just a basic ball over the top of him. It’s his problem to start with,” Neville said during the Anfield commentary. He added that De Ligt was “miles away” from the ball and that his poor anticipation forced Yoro into a desperate challenge.
The criticism grew as Isak repeatedly found space against De Ligt. One moment saw Isak nutmeg De Ligt, drawing an audible gasp from co-commentator Jamie Carragher. Later, De Ligt misjudged a pass that allowed Isak another clear chance to score. Neville compared De Ligt’s performance to someone returning from a long injury lay-off and joked, “It’s almost as if you’ve had six pints.”
Despite his shaky display, Pochettino kept De Ligt on the pitch for over 70 minutes, a decision that did not pay off for the new Manchester United manager. The team eventually fell apart as Liverpool added two more goals, leaving United to face a humiliating defeat.
De Ligt’s uncertain future at Old Trafford was already a topic of conversation. Neville’s public call for the club to get rid of him compounds the pressure on the player and the management. Pochettino’s gamble to start De Ligt backfired, highlighting the difficulty Manchester United faces in strengthening their defensive options.
The debate over De Ligt’s place in the squad continues as United prepare for the busy run of fixtures ahead. His injury record and inconsistent form remain obstacles to regaining a regular spot in the team under Pochettino’s management.
According to Planet Football.









