‘£50m wasted!’ – Paul Ince slams Man Utd for Andrey Santos transfer and labels club a ‘shambles’

Paul Ince criticizes Man Utd's £50m Andrey Santos transfer, calling the club a 'shambles.' Read why Ince is so harsh on the Red Devils.

‘£50m wasted!’ – Paul Ince slams Man Utd for Andrey Santos transfer and labels club a ‘shambles’

Manchester United’s £50 million signing of Andrey Santos has drawn sharp criticism from former midfielder Paul Ince, who labelled the transfer a “waste” and described the club as a “shambles.” The ex-England international took aim at the Red Devils’ summer recruitment strategy, questioning the logic behind such a hefty outlay on Santos when the squad’s weaknesses lie elsewhere.

Santos joined Manchester United from Chelsea alongside Youri Tielemans and Carlos Baleba, with the club hoping to strengthen midfield options. Yet, Santos started only four of the first ten Premier League matches under then-manager Michael Carrick. The managerial change that brought Mauricio Pochettino to Old Trafford has yet to alter Ince’s view on the transfer.

Andrey Santos In this story Andrey Santos Midfielder · Manchester United · 5 apps, 0 goals this season View profile

“Why did they spend £50m on Santos?” Ince told The Sun. “That’s £50m wasted. They could have put that into the defence or bought a striker. They have [Kobbie] Mainoo, who needs to develop. He needs to be playing, not Santos.”

Ince’s criticism extended beyond Santos, taking in the other midfield signings. He questioned Tielemans’ ability to meet the heightened demands at United despite his strong performances at Aston Villa. Meanwhile, Baleba, signed for £70 million, has struggled with injuries, limiting his impact on the team.

“Tielemans, again, fantastic at Villa but it’s a different conversation when you come to United,” Ince added. “Baleba didn’t play a lot last year. He comes in for £70m, plays a couple of games and he’s injured again.”

Ince highlighted the physical nature of the current Premier League, suggesting United’s midfield lacks the strength required to compete consistently. He referenced Pep Guardiola’s frequent comments on the importance of winning duels and tackles, pointing out that the game demands more than just passing ability.

“The game’s changing. It’s not all pass, pass, pass now. You’ve got to win your duels. You used to hear Pep Guardiola say every time, ‘We didn’t win our duels, we didn’t win our tackles.’ The game’s more physical, more powerful.”

The former midfielder also voiced concerns about Manchester United’s broader recruitment and squad building since the departure of Sir Alex Ferguson. Ince argued the club’s reputation has suffered, affecting their ability to attract elite talent like Declan Rice or Jude Bellingham, both of whom have been linked with United in recent transfer speculation.

“Since Sir Alex Ferguson left it’s been a complete disaster,” Ince said. “Would every player in the world want to come to United? They don’t, because it’s a basket case there, a shambles.”

Pochettino is expected to receive financial backing to strengthen the squad in the January transfer window. Yet Ince remains sceptical about whether the club can secure top-tier signings amid ongoing instability.

The Brazilian midfielder Santos, despite the significant investment, has yet to convince many observers at Old Trafford, with his limited Premier League starts under Carrick and uncertain role under Pochettino. Meanwhile, the future of other expensive recruits like Baleba remains unclear due to fitness concerns.

Manchester United’s defensive and attacking lines were the areas Ince suggested needed investment, pointing to the lack of quality in those positions compared with midfield depth. The former player’s comments underline continued scrutiny on the club’s transfer strategy amid a season that has seen mixed results and questions about squad balance.

This week’s developments at Old Trafford, including the managerial change and upcoming transfer window, will test whether the club can overcome its current challenges and improve its standing in the Premier League.


According to Yahoo Sports.

Reported and edited by SCN Newsroom. Corrections policy

More on Manchester United

All Manchester United news