Xavier holds 4-15 record against AP No. 1 teams including historic 1996 win at UC

Xavier basketball holds a 4-15 record against AP No. 1 teams, including their historic 1996 win at UC.

Xavier holds 4-15 record against AP No. 1 teams including historic 1996 win at UC

Thirty years ago, Xavier guard Lenny Brown sank a buzzer-beater that lifted the Musketeers to a 71-69 upset over No. 1-ranked Cincinnati at Shoemaker Center. That victory remains the only time Xavier has beaten the top-ranked team on the road and helped reset the dynamic between the two programs in the Crosstown Shootout rivalry. Prior to that, Cincinnati held a 43-20 advantage; since then, Xavier has won 21 of the last 30 meetings.

Xavier’s all-time record against AP No. 1 teams stands at 4-15, stretching back to the inception of the poll in 1948-49. The Musketeers have faced some of college basketball’s most storied programs at their peak, including Kentucky, Cincinnati, Indiana, Notre Dame, and Villanova.

In the early years, Kentucky, led by coach Adolph Rupp, dominated Xavier. The Wildcats were No. 1 in five matchups against Xavier and won them all. During the 1948-49 season, Kentucky swept Xavier twice within 12 days, winning 96-50 at home and 51-40 in Cincinnati Gardens. Kentucky went 32-2 that season and captured its second consecutive national title. They went on to beat Xavier again in 1951 by wide margins, including a 97-52 win at Cincinnati Gardens.

Cincinnati’s first meeting against Xavier as a top-ranked team took place on March 8, 1960, at Armory Fieldhouse. The Bearcats, led by Oscar Robertson’s 25 points, pulled away for an 86-68 win and advanced to the Final Four. Xavier ran into No. 1 UC again in 1963, losing 72-61 at Cincinnati Gardens after the Bearcats had claimed back-to-back national championships.

Xavier’s encounters with other No. 1 teams included a 1979 loss to Notre Dame. The Fighting Irish, led by Kelly Tripucka and coached by Digger Phelps, were ranked No. 1 in January 1979. Notre Dame defeated Xavier 66-57 at Purcell Pavilion on February 1, with current Xavier broadcaster Joe Sunderman scoring six points.

Indiana, under Bobby Knight, handed Xavier two losses as the nation’s top team. The first came in December 1979, a 92-66 blowout with Mike Woodson scoring 33 points. In 1993, Xavier fell 73-70 to Indiana in the NCAA Tournament second round at the RCA Dome, just 50 miles from Indiana’s campus.

Xavier’s closest brush with another No. 1 team before the Brown buzzer-beater came in 1996 against John Calipari’s UMass Minutemen. Xavier led 67-62 with under three minutes remaining at Cincinnati Gardens, but UMass junior Edgar Padilla, who had shot 2-of-12, hit a contested three-pointer with 15 seconds left to force overtime. UMass won 78-74.

Three years later, in the final Crosstown Shootout at Cincinnati Gardens, Xavier edged No. 1 Cincinnati again, this time 66-64, thanks to Kevin Frey’s breakaway layup with 12 seconds left. Xavier would also win at Shoemaker Center in 2000, but Cincinnati took the first shootout at Cintas Center in 2001.

In 2003, No. 1 Alabama defeated No. 19 Xavier 65-58. David West led Xavier with 16 points and eight rebounds. The following year, Xavier knocked St. Joseph’s, then ranked No. 1, out of the top spot with an 87-67 win in the Atlantic 10 Tournament. Lionel Chalmers, Anthony Myles, and Romain Sato combined for 66 points against the Hawks, who featured future NBA All-Star Jameer Nelson.

Xavier’s most recent NCAA Tournament loss to a No. 1 team came in 2007 against Ohio State, coached by former Xavier head coach Thad Matta. Ron Lewis’s three-pointer with two seconds left sent the game into overtime, where Ohio State won 78-71.

The Musketeers’ last victory over a No. 1 team happened in 2016 when they upset Villanova 90-83 at Cintas Center. That season, Xavier reached as high as No. 5 in the AP Poll under coach Chris Mack. Villanova avenged the loss two years later, beating Xavier 89-65 in Philadelphia.

Xavier’s most lopsided defeat against a No. 1 team occurred in 2024 when UConn routed the Musketeers 99-56 at the XL Center in Hartford. UConn opened with a 10-0 run and went on to win its second consecutive national title. Xavier was on track for its first losing season in nearly 30 years at the time.

Xavier’s 4-15 record versus AP No. 1 teams reflects a history of facing elite opponents under varying circumstances, from historic rivalries to tournament battles. Their wins remain scattered moments of upset amid years of challenging matchups against the nation’s top-ranked squads.


According to Yahoo Sports.

Reported and edited by SCN Newsroom. Corrections policy

Latest news

All news