Indiana coach Curt Cignetti’s gamble to bench his regular kicker Nico Radicic in favour of Paddy McAteer backfired in overtime during a 27-24 loss to Washington. McAteer missed a 37-yard field goal attempt that would have extended the game, handing the Hoosiers a narrow defeat.
The decision came after Radicic had a 46-yard field goal blocked in the third quarter. Cignetti said the move was motivated by Indiana’s struggles with field goals this season. “We missed too many field goals this year,” he told reporters. “And the other guy had made them. That was the plan going in. We gave him an opportunity and he missed a field goal.”
Radicic had enjoyed strong form in recent seasons, going 28 of 30 on field goal attempts in 2024-25 and earning Big Ten Kicker of the Year honours last year. However, this season he had been replaced by McAteer, who came into the game with a less reliable record, making two of four attempts. McAteer’s most notable success was a program-record 60-yard field goal against Minnesota in a high-pressure situation.
McAteer did convert a 34-yard field goal to give Indiana a 17-14 lead with just over six minutes remaining in the third quarter. Despite this, the overtime opportunity proved costly when his 37-yard kick failed to find the posts.
Cignetti explained his choice to stick with McAteer in overtime despite the miss. “But how do you go back to the other guy when this guy drilled a 60 yard to win the game and drilled the one opportunity he had?” he said.
Indiana’s special teams had been inconsistent throughout the season, a problem that contributed to the Hoosiers’ 9-2 record and 6-2 standing in the Big Ten. The loss to Washington further dims their chances of making the College Football Playoff, according to analysis from local media.
Michael Niziolek, the Indiana beat reporter for The Bloomington Herald-Times, covered the game and the fallout. The Hoosiers’ struggles with kicking have drawn close scrutiny after the game, with some questioning the timing and impact of Cignetti’s decision.
Washington’s victory came despite Indiana’s strong push late in the game, with the Hoosiers unable to capitalise on their scoring chances in overtime. The special teams’ performance remained a concern for Indiana’s coaching staff as the season approaches its final stages.
Cignetti’s move to switch kickers was clear from the outset of the second half, prompted by the blocked attempt from Radicic. McAteer’s earlier success, including his 60-yard field goal, had earned him the trust of the coaching staff, but the missed kick in overtime left the team short.
Indiana’s next games will be watched closely to see if the kicking situation stabilises or if further changes are made. For now, the Hoosiers must regroup after a narrow loss that hinged on a single missed field goal in overtime.
According to Yahoo Sports.





