New York Giants hold steady mid-rank despite narrow loss as Isaiah Likely shines

New York Giants remain steady mid-rank despite a narrow loss, with Isaiah Likely delivering an impressive performance. See the latest updates here.

New York Giants hold steady mid-rank despite narrow loss as Isaiah Likely shines

The New York Giants fell 24-21 to the Washington Commanders last Thursday night, dropping a game they had chances to secure in the fourth quarter. Isaiah Likely made a strong impression with nine catches for a career-high 127 yards and a 66-yard touchdown that briefly put the Giants ahead. Meanwhile, J.J. McCarthy threw for a career-high 293 yards, demonstrating growth despite the narrow loss.

The defeat has kept the Giants in a mid-tier position in NFL power rankings heading into Week 11. At 5-3-1, they remain in contention in the NFC East but have yet to prove they can close out tight games. The division is increasingly tight following the loss, with Washington and Dallas both showing weaknesses. ESPN’s NFL Nation ranks the Giants 15th, noting Likely as a standout player whose consistency has been a bright spot amid the offense’s struggles.

McCarthy’s performances have drawn mixed reviews, but his progress since joining the Giants midseason is visible. Since Week 6, he ranks 10th in adjusted EPA per play among quarterbacks with at least 100 plays, according to Yahoo! Sports’ Frank Schwab. McCarthy has thrown for 915 yards in just three starts this season, compared to 1,632 yards in 10 starts with the Vikings in 2025. Bleacher Report sees potential in him, suggesting the Giants could evaluate their quarterback options as the season unfolds.

The Giants’ offense failed to capitalise on two key opportunities late in the game, going three-and-out when holding the lead. They intercepted Washington quarterback Jayden Daniels twice in the fourth quarter yet allowed Stefon Diggs to score the game-winning touchdown under a minute to play. FOX Sports’ Ralph Vacchiano pointed to the team’s lack of “killer instinct,” citing these missed chances as evidence the Giants still need to develop that edge.

Special teams have also been a point of concern. USA TODAY’s Nate Davis highlighted the Giants’ average starting field position at their own 28.6-yard line, the worst in the league. He suggested that a team led by special teams expert John Harbaugh should be able to improve in this area.

Tight end Isaiah Likely’s emergence has been a major positive. He leads the team with seven touchdowns and has 575 receiving yards this season, ranking only behind Brock Bowers and Trey McBride among NFL tight ends. His reliability is reflected in his six games with at least 50 receiving yards and just one drop, according to ESPN. Likely has benefited from working with multiple quarterbacks, including Jaxson Dart, Jameis Winston, and McCarthy.

The Giants face a challenging schedule ahead, including matchups against the 7-2 Jacksonville Jaguars, San Francisco 49ers, and Seattle Seahawks. Sports Illustrated’s Connor Orr ranks the Giants 11th and notes they still control their fate in the NFC East. However, the loss to Washington complicates their path, with the division far from decided.

Walter Football sees the Giants’ schedule as fairly fortunate so far but warns the recent loss may indicate the team’s luck is running out. The Athletic’s Chad Graff ranks the Giants 16th, down one spot from the previous week, reflecting the disappointment felt within the organization and fanbase.

General manager Joe Schoen and head coach John Harbaugh will likely continue to weigh their options at quarterback as the season progresses, especially with McCarthy showing promise and Dart waiting in the wings. The team’s ability to improve execution on offense and special teams will be tested in the coming weeks as they try to maintain their position in the NFC East and push toward the playoffs.


According to Yahoo Sports.

Reported and edited by SCN Newsroom. Corrections policy

Latest news

All news